Trick or Treating

You went trick or treating as Loki.
Horatio gave you ATomato.
Zoidberg gave you AnApple.
Destiny gave you TheElixirofLife.
TomSawyer gave you ASpork.
You had a terrific time until Aramis killed your parents.

What's Your Trick-or-Treat Haul?
Shiver My Timber--A Pirate RPG